India’s inward turn could stymie its rise
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard

Sunday
February 05, 2023

Sign In
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
SUNDAY, FEBRUARY 05, 2023
India’s inward turn could stymie its rise

South Asia

Andy Mukherjee, Bloomberg
17 January, 2022, 06:30 pm
Last modified: 17 January, 2022, 06:51 pm

Related News

  • Indian watchdog tells investors markets stable despite Adani rout
  • US FDA says India-made eye drop linked to some infections, blindness and one death
  • Adani crisis not going to be indicative of how well Indian financial markets governed: Finance minister
  • Russia in favour of India becoming permanent member of UNSC: Envoy
  • Indian police arrest 1,800 men in crackdown on underage marriage

India’s inward turn could stymie its rise

Modi is hoping the country’s consumers will constitute a big enough market to power the economy. That could be a major miscalculation

Andy Mukherjee, Bloomberg
17 January, 2022, 06:30 pm
Last modified: 17 January, 2022, 06:51 pm
India’s inward turn could stymie its rise

Shortly before the 2014 election that made him prime minister, Narendra Modi came up with the idea that India's young population, constitutional checks on arbitrary political power and large domestic market would bring prosperity over a decade. He even coined a slogan, calling it the nation's 3D advantage — demographics, democracy and demand.   

India's democratic institutions, such as the judiciary and a free press, have frayed under Modi. With just over 40% of the labor force engaged in the economy — among the worst rates of worker participation anywhere in the world — the youth-bulge narrative has also lost its sheen. What remains of the 2014 mantra is demand. But how big an advantage is the domestic Indian economy? Can an inward-looking growth strategy create enough jobs and attract the capital that's fleeing China?   

In a Foreign Affairs article, economist Arvind Subramanian, an adviser to the Modi administration until 2018, and Josh Felman, a former International Monetary Fund representative in New Delhi, have attempted to answer these questions. Team Modi has done a decent job providing physical and digital infrastructure as well as basic services like cheap housing, electricity, water, cooking gas and bank accounts; but this boosting of the "hardware" of the economy, the authors argue, has been accompanied by a weakening of its "software," including the centerpiece of the government's growth framework — its industrial policy.

The chest-thumping nationalism of the last eight years has led to a repudiation of the gradual opening up of the previous three decades. More than 3,000 tariff increases have affected 70% of imports. India entered 11 trade agreements in the 10 years under previous Prime Minister Manmohan Singh. On Modi's watch, it hasn't signed even one. Although the country is starting negotiations with post-Brexit Britain and Australia, and claims to be close to a pact with the United Arab Emirates, bilateral deals won't compensate for the Regional Comprehensive Economic Partnership, a free-trade accord linking Asia's exporting powerhouses. New Delhi turned its back on RCEP in 2019. 

This protectionist drift springs from the belief that an economy of 1.4 billion consumers is large enough to be powered by internal demand. But, as Subramanian's previous work with Pennsylvania State University economist Shoumitro Chatterjee has shown, even before Covid-19, no more than 1%-to-2% of the population could be described as middle class, compared with 25% in China. Such a tiny font of purchasing power could at best drive $500 billion in spending. World trade, meanwhile, is a $28 trillion opportunity, with much smaller countries like Vietnam making a determined play to win market share. 

The World's Next Factory

As China's share of world imports starts to plateau, Vietnam is stealing a march over more-populous India

Will self-reliant India work? Subramanian and Felman are skeptical. "India has seen this movie before," they say. Indeed, the current leitmotif is reminiscent of the pre-1991 "license raj," in which the state controlled capacity in the private sector, but shielded it from global competition by erecting high tariff walls. The lynchpin of the new system is subsidies, with New Delhi promising 2 trillion rupees ($27 billion) to investors for making their widgets in India. The idea is to dangle fiscal sops in front of a company like Tesla Inc. and win a large electric-vehicle factory. (Elon Musk, however, is proving to be a hard catch.)

India is parched for capital expenditure, and its trade deficits are ballooning, particularly with China. Every new investment is a victory of sorts for policymakers. Still, a "subsidy raj" carries all the risks of the old license regime: "It is hard to enforce, is driven by arbitrary decision-making, and creates a system of entitlements from which it will be difficult to exit," according to Subramanian and Felman.

It's impossible to become a factory to the world by coaxing firms to substitute imports with domestic production. Take mobile phones. Two years of tariff increases on camera modules, display and touch panels, printed circuit boards, and parts used in chargers have pushed up the cost of assembly in India by 8%. That's about 6% of a phone's ex-factory price and fully negates the 5% subsidy on offer, according to a study by the country's Cellular & Electronics Association. The net benefit for Make in India is zero.

A Tale of Two Industrial Policies

Vietnam pegs half of the 120 tariff lines relevant to the mobile phone industry at zero; India imposes 15%-plus duties on a quarter of imported parts

Source: India Cellular & Electronics Association
Source: India Cellular & Electronics Association

Contrast this with Vietnam, which is copying the winning formula of East Asian Tiger economies: free and frictionless trade. Out of 120 tariff lines of relevance to the handset industry, 59 are duty-free in Vietnam, compared with only 32 in India. And while India imposes import duties of 15% or more on 28 items, Vietnam's tariffs are that high only for 16 components. These, too, are mostly sourced from countries with which Vietnam has free-trade deals. So they're effectively zero-duty imports as well. 

India's inward turn has coincided with a rise in economic concentration. Just two conglomerates, led by billionaire tycoons Mukesh Ambani and Gautam Adani, have amassed vast influence across sectors. The danger of depending on a small coterie of national champions is that it won't build widespread public support for market-based reforms. "In fact, it already has turned many Indians against them," Subramanian and Felman say, citing the yearlong farmers' protests that forced Modi to drop his plan of a market-oriented makeover of agriculture. 

The pandemic has hollowed out India's middle class by destroying 10 million manufacturing jobs. Industrial output in November was slightly lower than two years ago. And yet, by skipping out on large free-trade areas and putting up protectionist obstacles, New Delhi is crimping the country's chances in labor-intensive industries like textiles and footwear — just as China is vacating the space because it has run out of cheap labor. For a second time in India's history, self-reliance might prove to be a costly mistake. 


Andy Mukherjee is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering industrial companies and financial services. He previously was a columnist for Reuters Breakingviews. He has also worked for the Straits Times, ET NOW and Bloomberg News.


Disclaimer: This article first appeared on Bloomberg, and is published by special syndication arrangement 

Top News / World+Biz / Global Economy

India / Modi government / Narendra Modi / Indian PM Narendra Modi / Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi / India 2014 election / Modi election mantra / India economy

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Master plan for futuristic Chattogram city in the making
    Master plan for futuristic Chattogram city in the making
  • Consumers should pay the actual costs to get gas and electricity: PM
    Consumers should pay the actual costs to get gas and electricity: PM
  • Pakistan's former president Pervez Musharraf dies in Dubai after prolonged illness
    Pakistan's former president Pervez Musharraf dies in Dubai after prolonged illness

MOST VIEWED

  • Photo: Collected
    Pervez Musharraf: The Pakistani ex-president’s chequered legacy
  •  Pakistan's President Pervez Musharraf arrives to meet Britain's Prime Minister Gordon Brown in Downing Street in London January 28, 2008. REUTERS/Stephen Hird
    Reaction to death of former Pakistan President Musharraf
  • Former Pakistan President Pervez Musharraf meets journalists after attending the CLSA Investors Forum in Hong Kong in this September 15, 2010 file photo/ Reuters
    Musharraf: Who came closest to Kashmir solution but also triggered Kargil war
  • Pakistan's former President, Pervez Musharraf, addresses his supporters after his arrival from Dubai at Jinnah International airport in Karachi March 24, 2013. Musharraf returned home on Sunday after nearly four years of self-imposed exile to contest elections despite the possibility of arrest and a threat from the Taliban to kill him. REUTERS/Akhtar Soomro
    Pakistan's Musharraf, military ruler who allied with the US and promoted moderate Islam
  • Pakistan's former president Pervez Musharraf dies in Dubai after prolonged illness
    Pakistan's former president Pervez Musharraf dies in Dubai after prolonged illness
  • FILE PHOTO: The logo of the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) is pictured on the premises of its headquarters in Mumbai, India March 1, 2017. REUTERS/Shailesh Andrade/Files
    On Adani row, SEBI says it's committed to ensuring market integrity

Related News

  • Indian watchdog tells investors markets stable despite Adani rout
  • US FDA says India-made eye drop linked to some infections, blindness and one death
  • Adani crisis not going to be indicative of how well Indian financial markets governed: Finance minister
  • Russia in favour of India becoming permanent member of UNSC: Envoy
  • Indian police arrest 1,800 men in crackdown on underage marriage

Features

Aarong never ceases to surprise with their vibrant ensemble perfect for Fagun looks. Photo: Courtesy

Say it with Colours

5h | Mode
Photo: Courtesy

From 'Made in Bangladesh' to 'Designed in Bangladesh'

7h | Panorama
Google must adjust to a world where content is increasingly generated by AI. Photo: Bloomberg

Google will join the AI wars, pitting LaMDA against ChatGPT

4h | Panorama
The megaproject Rooppur Nuclear Power Plant has a debt of Tk90,474 crore. Photo: Courtesy

Projects funded with debt need to be selected prudently, and implemented timely

5h | Panorama

More Videos from TBS

Lack of coordination, policy biggest problems

Lack of coordination, policy biggest problems

1h | TBS Round Table
Industries panicked about continuing stresses on profitability

Industries panicked about continuing stresses on profitability

2h | TBS Round Table
One meal at Tk 20

One meal at Tk 20

2h | TBS Stories
International award at the age of 23

International award at the age of 23

2h | TBS Entertainment

Most Read

1
Leepu realised his love for cars from a young age and for the last 40 years, he has transformed, designed and customised hundreds of cars. Photo: Collected
Panorama

'I am not crazy about cars anymore': Nizamuddin Awlia Leepu

2
The International Monetary Fund (IMF) logo is seen outside the headquarters building in Washington, U.S., September 4, 2018. REUTERS/Yuri Gripas/File Photo
Economy

IMF approves $4.7 billion loan for Bangladesh, calls for ambitious reforms

3
Fund cut as Dhaka's fast-track transit projects on slow spending lane
Infrastructure

Fund cut as Dhaka's fast-track transit projects on slow spending lane

4
Photo: Collected
Court

Japanese mother gets guardianship of daughters, free to leave country

5
Belal Ahmed new acting chairman of SIBL
Banking

Belal Ahmed new acting chairman of SIBL

6
Photo: Collected
Startups

ShopUp secures $30m debt financing to boost expansion, supply chain

EMAIL US
contact@tbsnews.net
FOLLOW US
WHATSAPP
+880 1847416158
The Business Standard
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Copyright © 2023
The Business Standard All rights reserved
Technical Partner: RSI Lab

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - oped.tbs@gmail.com

For advertisement- sales@tbsnews.net