Judges, not voters, may decide on Scottish independence vote
Skip to main content
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
The Business Standard

Monday
January 30, 2023

Sign In
Subscribe
  • Home
  • Economy
    • Aviation
    • Bazaar
    • Budget
    • Industry
    • NBR
    • RMG
    • Corporates
  • Stocks
  • Analysis
  • World+Biz
  • Sports
  • Features
    • Book Review
    • Brands
    • Earth
    • Explorer
    • Fact Check
    • Family
    • Food
    • Game Reviews
    • Good Practices
    • Habitat
    • Humour
    • In Focus
    • Luxury
    • Mode
    • Panorama
    • Pursuit
    • Wealth
    • Wellbeing
    • Wheels
  • Epaper
  • More
    • Subscribe
    • Videos
    • Thoughts
    • Splash
    • Bangladesh
    • Supplement
    • Infograph
    • Archive
    • COVID-19
    • Games
    • Long Read
    • Interviews
    • Offbeat
    • Podcast
    • Quiz
    • Tech
    • Trial By Trivia
    • Magazine
  • বাংলা
MONDAY, JANUARY 30, 2023
Judges, not voters, may decide on Scottish independence vote

World+Biz

Reuters
05 February, 2021, 07:30 pm
Last modified: 05 February, 2021, 07:37 pm

Related News

  • Questions as 80 lakh citizens added to voter list
  • PM seeks vote for boat at massive Ctg rally
  • EC updates voter list ahead of next general election
  • Bangladesh, India, 71 other nations abstain from UN vote seeking Russian reparations to Ukraine
  • CCTV cams do not compromise voters' privacy: EC

Judges, not voters, may decide on Scottish independence vote

Surveys suggest that Scottish voters, who rejected secession in 2014 but are now frustrated by being taken out of the European Union against their will, would this time vote for independence

Reuters
05 February, 2021, 07:30 pm
Last modified: 05 February, 2021, 07:37 pm
FILE PHOTO: People hold a Scottish flag featuring the stars of the European Union flag as they gather on the streets on Brexit day, in Edinburgh, Scotland, Britain January 31, 2020. REUTERS/Russell Cheyne/File Photo
FILE PHOTO: People hold a Scottish flag featuring the stars of the European Union flag as they gather on the streets on Brexit day, in Edinburgh, Scotland, Britain January 31, 2020. REUTERS/Russell Cheyne/File Photo

Scotland's top civil court dealt nationalists a blow on Friday by declining to rule that the Scottish parliament had the right to call an independence referendum without London's permission.

In the first skirmish of what is likely to become a major legal battle, the Court of Session in Edinburgh said it was premature and hypothetical to challenge Prime Minister Boris Johnson's power to block a new secession vote.

But, with the Scottish National Party (SNP) set for a big win in May's election to the Edinburgh parliament on the promise of a referendum, the fate of the 300-year-old union of Scotland with the rest of the United Kingdom is by no means assured.

Surveys suggest that Scottish voters, who rejected secession in 2014 but are now frustrated by being taken out of the European Union against their will, would this time vote for independence. Johnson may therefore need the UK Supreme Court to uphold his veto on such a vote taking place.

"I don't see how you can avoid going to the court," said David Hope, former deputy president of the Supreme Court.

A poll last month indicated the ruling SNP would capture 71 of 129 seats in Scotland's parliament, the biggest majority since the assembly was formed. Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon, the SNP leader, has vowed to hold a referendum early in the new parliament.

But the 1998 Scotland Act, which devolved some powers to Edinburgh and created the Scottish assembly, says matters relating to the union of the two countries can be decided only by the UK parliament in Westminster.

To stray from that, the UK parliament must agree to grant Scotland's government powers using a "Section 30 order" - as it did when approving the 2014 referendum, in which Scots rejected independence by 55%-45%.

'Once in A Generation'

Johnson says that was a "once in a generation" vote and has ruled out granting permission for another.

"The political pressure may well prevail in the sense that in the end Boris Johnson has to simply give way for political reasons," Hope told Reuters. "But without a Section 30 order, I don't see how a measure which directly attacks the union can get away with it."

The SNP says it will go ahead regardless, and force Johnson to test the issue in court.

Hope doubted whether it could succeed.

"They are trapped within a statute which is very carefully drafted," he said. "There is an argument, I suppose, about the democratic will of the people, but I don't think that arrives in the provision of the Scotland Act, because it (the Act) is looking at both sides."

However, Professor Aileen McHarg, a UK constitutional law expert from Durham University, said there were "respectable arguments" for concluding that the Scottish Parliament did have the right to pass a referendum bill without London's approval.

Facing such legal hurdles, some nationalists believe the SNP should either push ahead with a referendum, with or without a legal basis, or try to make May's election a proxy vote on whether Scotland should be independent.

"Court a gamble plus (Westminster) could bring in legislation to 'clarify' powers of Scot(tish) Parl(iament)," Angus MacNeil, an SNP member of the Westminster parliament, tweeted last month. "Then the opportunity is gone. Use the May Election".

Hope and McHarg both said a vote held without legal authority, similar to one in Catalonia in 2017, had little prospect of success.

For one thing, without international legitimacy, Scotland would have little prospect of rejoining the European Union, as the SNP wants.

"I think we are talking about a lawful referendum or no referendum at all," McHarg said.

judges / voters / Scottish / Independence / Vote

Comments

While most comments will be posted if they are on-topic and not abusive, moderation decisions are subjective. Published comments are readers’ own views and The Business Standard does not endorse any of the readers’ comments.

Top Stories

  • Photo: Bloomberg
    Adani rout hits $71 billion as fight with Hindenburg intensifies
  • Prime Minister Sheikh Hasina. Sketch: TBS
    Continued democracy helps rapid development: PM Hasina
  • Photo: Collected
    Zamzam Well water sale halted at Baitul Mukarram market

MOST VIEWED

  • Photo:Reuters
    World 'dangerously unprepared' for next crisis: Red Cross
  • A nurse prepares a shot for Jonathan Halter as the German embassy begins its roll out of BioNTech COVID-19 vaccines for German expatriates at a Beijing United Family hospital in Beijing, China January 5, 2023. REUTERS/Thomas Peter/File Photo
    Covid remains a public health emergency, says WHO
  • A police officer guides an ambulance after a suicide blast in a mosque, at police line area in Peshawar, Pakistan January 30, 2023. REUTERS/Fayaz Aziz
    Suicide bombing at mosque in Pakistan kills 32, targeted police
  • FILE PHOTO: A child holds the national flags of Russia and China prior to a welcoming ceremony for Russian President Vladimir Putin outside the Great Hall of the People in Beijing, China, June 25, 2016. REUTERS/Kim Kyung-Hoon
    Russia seeks 'new level' of China ties
  • Representational Image. Photo: BBC
    Blast in mosque in Pakistan's Peshawar, at least 90 wounded
  • Photo: Bloomberg
    Adani rout hits $71 billion as fight with Hindenburg intensifies

Related News

  • Questions as 80 lakh citizens added to voter list
  • PM seeks vote for boat at massive Ctg rally
  • EC updates voter list ahead of next general election
  • Bangladesh, India, 71 other nations abstain from UN vote seeking Russian reparations to Ukraine
  • CCTV cams do not compromise voters' privacy: EC

Features

Photo: Courtesy

The Hawkers: Where minimalism meets motifs

8h | Brands
TBS illustration

Where do Shariah-compliant mutual funds stand in Bangladesh

7h | Panorama
Sketch: TBS

A subsidy war without winners

7h | Panorama
Photo: Collected

Oppo Reno 8T first look revealed!

8h | Brands

More Videos from TBS

Youths at the invitation of TBS

Youths at the invitation of TBS

2h | TBS Graduates
Predicting next three years is tough- Kutubuddin Ahmed

Predicting next three years is tough- Kutubuddin Ahmed

3h | TBS Round Table
Pakistan plunges into economic mess

Pakistan plunges into economic mess

6h | TBS World
Shahrukh's 'Pathaan' has been making records ever since its release

Shahrukh's 'Pathaan' has been making records ever since its release

6h | TBS Entertainment

Most Read

1
Picture: Collected
Bangladesh

US Embassy condemns recent incidents of visa fraud

2
Illustration: TBS
Banking

16 banks at risk of capital shortfall if top 3 borrowers default

3
Bapex calls candidates for job test 9 years after advert!
Bangladesh

Bapex calls candidates for job test 9 years after advert!

4
Photo: Collected
Splash

Hansal Mehta responds as Twitter user calls him 'shameless' for making Faraaz

5
A frozen Beyond Burger plant-based patty. Photographer: AKIRA for Bloomberg Businessweek
Bloomberg Special

Fake meat was supposed to save the world. It became just another fad

6
Representational Image
Banking

Cash-strapped Islami, Al-Arafah and National turn to Sonali Bank for costly fund

EMAIL US
contact@tbsnews.net
FOLLOW US
WHATSAPP
+880 1847416158
The Business Standard
  • About Us
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Privacy Policy
  • Comment Policy
Copyright © 2023
The Business Standard All rights reserved
Technical Partner: RSI Lab

Contact Us

The Business Standard

Main Office -4/A, Eskaton Garden, Dhaka- 1000

Phone: +8801847 416158 - 59

Send Opinion articles to - oped.tbs@gmail.com

For advertisement- sales@tbsnews.net